Wednesday, January 18, 2023

2/8…Critical Pedagogy

What is critical pedagogy and what you do think of it? What connections can you make between the idea of critical pedagogy and the Gutierrez article?

20 comments:

  1. Jocelyn McCall:
    Critical Pedagogy is a philosophy of education that combines ethics, social awareness, and promotion of equity within school/politics. It is developed from social theory and it is meant to not only acknowledge systematic means of oppression but to actively use education to find solutions that make the conditions better for students and their communities. Personally, I really think this is something I would like to take into account when developing my own teaching philosophy. I think Freire makes really good points and provides a pathway to critically look at these problems from an education standpoint. Theorists I have learned from have developed a lot of the foundations of their beliefs from this text, which is really cool to me.
    As I was reading the Gutierrez article, I noticed that they were discussing the exact premise of this framework. Specifically, they used it to critique standardized testing of mathematics while providing a way that doesn't reduce teachers or students to test scores. The example Gutierrez provided, which was using mathematics to collect data for concerns in the education system, is a great way to acknowledge issues in our country. In addition to, getting students both engaged with math skills, and work that has to get done to lessen inequalities.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ajaya-Kamari Barnhardt

    Critical pedagogy is a democratic relationship between equals who are willing to learn from each other. I really like this type of teacher student relationship because it brings about conversations and it will also help students learns. As for me I am an auditory learner and having conversations and discussions helps me learn better.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Erin Malloy:
    Critical pedagogy is a way of teaching that encourages input from students, critical questioning, application, and action. I think that critical pedagogy is a way of teaching that facilitates a student's development both academically as well as morally and ethically which is incredibly important in order to produce a more democratic society. In the Gutierrez article they criticize standardized testing and emphasize how it encourages separation among students and loss of equity in schools. This relates to critical pedagogy in that critical pedagogy aims to reduce inequity and separation that is created by standardized testing and therefore the majority of public schools.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jade Kokason
    Critical pedagogy is a philosophy of education and social movement that applies critical theory and related traditions to education and the study of culture. It emphasizes that issues of social justice and democracy aren't distinct from teaching and learning. One thing that stuck out to me in the article was the academic gap and how it was racially motivated. All kids learn differently and things such as standardized testing seem meant to weed those students out, placing them in a mindset that they can't ever reach higher levels.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Isabel Pepol-

    Paulo Freire’s definition of critical pedagogy is, “the belief that teaching should challenge learners to examine power structures and patterns of inequality within the status quo.” I agree with this idea of teaching because it creates a more open space for students to learn in. I believe that the Gutierrez article aligns with the ideas of critical pedagogy. This is because the issue of teaching as a sole purpose to create great test scores is brought up within the article and shows how teachers should start teaching in a way that aligns with critical pedagogy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anna Jarvis
    Critical Pedagogy: This is a philosophical proposal that explains 2 propositions. "Oppression exists" and "Transformation of the oppressed is possible". The way I took these propositions is that injustice within the education system needs to be acknowledged in order to come up with solutions resulting in a positively effective transformation. Those who are oppressed have higher rates of poverty, incarceration, and health struggles. This leads to what is explained as a "gap" between not only student opportunity, but relationships to teachers as well. Oppression cannot be ignored, as ignoring it is inhumane. The pedagogy of the oppressed gives a look at the education system in a more GENUINELY democratic way with outcomes of equal opportunity and teacher-student equality.
    A connection I make to the Gutierrez article is that both beliefs are similar. With an example of the gap explained as the test score gap between marginalized groups of students and dominant groups, this covers the "realization & transformation" proposition of the Pedagogy of the Oppressed. In order for change to happen, it needs to be acknowledged and reflected upon.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Vanessa Rodriguez:
    Critical pedagogy promotes humanity while avoiding dehumanization. I think it is a philosophy of education that teachers should always take into account when teaching. Many teachers see students as less than, which means that they are actively discouraging critical thought and fighting against oppression. In the article, Gutierrez included the dimensions of equity, which are access, identity, power, and achievement. He stated that schools just look at the test scores and not if students are truly learning, which means they are mainly focusing on achievement and seeing students as a number. Since they only care about high scores, they are not letting students be themselves and better themselves. I think his points go together with the idea of critical pedagogy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Danielle Hall:
    Critical pedagogy describes that education is not separate from problems of social justice. Through this philosophy, students are taught how to think critically for themselves to combat issues that impact them and contribute to a more democratic society. I appreciate this ideology as someone who hopes to be a school counselor one day. Oftentimes, students are aware of the social inequities that are present; students who are members of minority groups have the mindset that they have fewer opportunities to succeed, creating a cycle in which students accept this “fate.” Instead, I think that we should tell students that these inequities do exist but that they have the power to fight back in a way and make a difference. The Gutierrez article discusses the importance of not emphasizing the “gaps” that exist in the education system; this creates a competitive school environment in which students accept that some are less likely to do well on tests than others. Instead, we should realize that this disparity exists and provide the opportunities and resources students need to defy those expectations. This relates to critical pedagogy, as it is teaching students to not accept the inequities that impact them. I think critical pedagogy is an empowering model, focusing on the strengths that students have, their ability to think, and their ability to speak for themselves. As a social work major, I am passionate about empowerment, so while this may be a more progressive idea, I hope to implement these practices in my future career.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Critical pedagogy is when different aspects are considered when teaching. These aspects include the importance of humans and their needs, contexts, and histories. It is multidimensional, and teaching can be viewed from different angles and how ethics is central to education. It is an encouraging way of teaching that challenges the students and listens to what they have to say. It connects with Gutierrez's article because he believes that teachers should teach in the critical pedagogy strategy.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Michael Morrissey
    Critical pedagogy describes a democratic relationship where teachers and students exist more as equals. This contrasts the typical teacher student hierarchy where the students often take a more passive role, and encourages dialogue between teacher and student. Paulo Freire was a proponent of the idea that effective education is fostered by an environment where equals can have dialogue and are able to learn from one another. I feel that this philosophy encourages engagement and critical thinking within students, as well as works to create more positive relationships between students and teachers.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Critical pedagogy goes against the idea the teachers are above students and essentially describes an equal relationship where teachers and students have a democratic relationship. In the Paulo Freire video, we learned that education is not separate from problems of social injustice. I think that this is very true. The example of how Freire was unable to do well in school because he was hungry because his family was poor is a very common example that happens throughout the United States. The idea of critical pedagogy of the Gutierrez Article go hand and hand with each other in the sense that education is multidimensional and society does play a large role in the success of students and their learning.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Critical Pedagogy is a philosophy of education that encourages social development/awareness , creativity, critical thinking and applying knowledge to the real world. The problem we have now is a lot of teachers teach for the students to memorize rather than learn the material long term. To actually understand why we need to know the information. The article also discusses how standardized testing was used to "see who's smarter" placing students in very unrealistic education standards.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The article talks about critical pedagogy in a way that it compares to educational standards and different relationships between students and teachers and how this affects how they learn. Critical pedagogy is a positive and progressive way of going about learning and establishing a student teacher relationship where students are able to have a sense of purpose and power in the system of school. It encourages students to stand up for what they believe in and not just let the teachers be the dictators and run the school and classes in a way that is unproductive for both the teacher and the student. It gives the example of the bigger idea that equality and social justice along with diversity and democracy and ethics that goes on outside of the school system as well.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Critical pedagogy is a teaching approach in which the students question and challenge what they are being taught. Doing this encourages students to be literary critics. Rather than be given a textbook and and accept the information they are being taught they are encouraged to question the information and have their own narrative. I think Gutierrez article he has a lot of the same ideas as the framework for critical pedagogy. He doesn't see standarized tests as the end all goal for learning. He views identity and power as the critical dimensions of equity. He discusses classroom environments that invite deep learning not just tangible student outcomes.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hannah Tijani
    Critical pedagogy is when students are able to state their thoughts and have a say in the way they learn. Critical pedagogy can be a positive way for expanding learning ways. It challenges students to expand the way they learn. I think it's an amazing way for students to get involved in different ways. I think a negative view point is sometimes students don't feel apart of these methods because scores are more important to them than the actual learning lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Emmie Weatherholtz

    In short, Critical Pedagogy is a way of looking at teaching and challenging methods used before. It talks about how there are things in the system that need to be fixed and talks a lot about oppression in our schools. It's a method that allows the students to argue their thoughts and fight for what they need out of their own education.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Lynnsi Joyce
    Critical pedagogy is a philosophy of teaching that centers around larger societal and moral dilemmas, rather than the traditional schooling content. With this philosophy, teachers and students are able to apply the knowledge and skills gained throughout their school and then use the theories of critical pedagogy to then problem solve and use critical thinking techniques as a means to potentially "solve" or at least notice the flaws in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Kimani Robinson:
    Critical Pedagogy refers to the philosophy of education that allows for learners to apply a critical lens to cultural, societal, and political systems based on the knowledge of current and historical informational context. This kind of philosophy in useful making sure our youth will be the most prepared for the realities of life, as many people would agree is the goal. The Gutierrez article criticizes standardized testing because it divides students into numbers when numbers can't quantify the true extent to someone intelligence, ability, or potential. This idea is itself an demonstration of Critical Pedagogy.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Callum Amend:
    Critical pedagogy is a broad concept that refers to thinking critically about the philosophy behind education and teaching and considering how to implement this in the classroom. It involves not blindly following the traditional model and considering students' individual needs and different factors that may affect someone's ability to learn or to get an education. The Gutierrez article describes the downfalls of standardized testing and looks at aspects of the traditional model of education critically, which is an example of Critical Pedagogy.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Critical pedagogy is for students to thinking critically about the information given to them. I personally don't like critical thinking when it comes to a lot of things like an example of critical pedagogy is a group of students reading about history from a textbook instead of retaining that information students should conduct their own research. I think this can be beneficial to many students but I personally didn't enjoy having to find more research on a topic I've read about already unless it was a subject that truly interested me and I wanted to know more about it. The Gutierrez article talks about the negative impact standardized testing which falls back on critical pedagogy students don't always learn the way we are being taught or tested.
    -Janika G.W

    ReplyDelete

1/23…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...