Wednesday, January 18, 2023

2/1…What is Teaching?

What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any other thoughts?

20 comments:

  1. Erin Malloy:
    Ayers' introduces two different styles of teaching that are imbued with politics. One way Ayers talks about teaching is referring to is as authoritarian, meaning that the teachers/administrators/adults decide what facts are to be presented, what is the right way to think about things, what the right answer is, etc. and students are meant to consume what they are told and then regurgitate it without questioning its validity or truth. The second way Ayers talks about teaching is referring to it as democratic, meaning that students are as much a part of the teaching and learning process as teachers are, and that education is meant to create a sense of community, curiosity, and the ability to think for oneself. A new way that Ayers brought up about understanding teaching was thinking of it as a moral and ethical responsibility and how teachers are some of the first people that students learn morals, ethics, and ways of being human from. Therefore teaching is more than just getting a student to learn, critically think, and question, it is also creating good humans that can then become productive and active members of society.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Emmie Weatherholtz:
    I think Ayer is right about the two different methods of teaching. As a student, I have seen both of them in action in the classroom with teachers in the past. Looking back on it, I can conclude that I enjoyed the teachers that used the democratic method more than an authoritarian one. I like the examples Ayer mentioned throughout the chapter that made each style a little bit easier to understand/relate to in a way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Danielle Hall:
    I appreciated Ayers’ perspective on teaching, as while it may not be as dramatic as some of the examples he provided, today’s education system can fit his authoritarian description. From my perspective, it is very easy for educators to get caught up in specific objectives they must meet for standardized testing. Students are told what to know and think, but they are not provided with many tools to succeed in the real world. In his democratic teaching approach, students would not necessarily be told what to think, but instead, they would be taught how to think. I liked that Ayers noted that teachers are just human; they are not better than everyone else and should not be given the responsibility to tell humans how to be good people. Rather, teachers can share what they know and provide opportunities for students to determine their own actions and behaviors. I think this is a new concept, as teachers are often placed on a pedestal (although their pay is not really evidence of that). Similar to doctors and lawyers, teachers have always been expected to behave a certain way, even off the job, in order to be good role models. While I agree that students need good role models, what does that really mean? This chapter really made me think about what is needed from a teacher in order to fulfill the many important purposes of education that Ayers described.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Jade Kokason:
    One thing that really stuck out to me is that he, in a more concise way, talked about how hard it is. You want to change the way children think and imbue them with knowledge to better suit them for the world, but there is always someone pulling the strings and there's basically tons of red tape to wade through. A big point is that it is very difficult to run a classroom in the perfect way, or make everyone happy.

    ReplyDelete

  5. Isabel Pepol-

    Ayer’s talks about teaching in two different ways: authoritarian and democratic. I have seen both teaching methods within the classroom. Throughout the article, the author brings up how important it is to choose a teaching style that you believe is ethical. Ethics is a big part of this article.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Vanessa Rodriguez:
    Ayer believes schooling can be a practice of dehumanization if used in the wrong way. He gave many examples of students being dehumanized and having their freedom taken away through schooling. Many teachers use force and power to get the results that they want, even if it means frightening and alarming their students. He made me understand that the enterprise is harder to achieve because some teaching methods do not help students reach their full potential.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Michael Morrissey
    I feel that in the current climate of the education system, I feel it is can be very easy for a lot of the typical school experience to fit into Ayer's description of authoritarian teaching. With the great deal of emphasis placed on standardized testing and teaching in correspondence with a curriculum, it is easy to see how that could be at odds with the idea that education is supposed to nourish people as individuals and create lifelong learners. I feel that often times within this style of teaching, students are treated more like products than individuals.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I believe that Ayer's way of talking about teaching matches what is currently is being practiced in the schooling system. With standardized tests becoming a great part of the curriculum and having a rubric system, many teachers can and do fall under the description of authoritarian teaching. This occurs because teachers are tasked with ensuring that the students are achieving very specific objectives, they become for strict and stern to ensure that specific information is being processed. The best way for students to thrive through and have a deeper understanding of the topics they are learning, their voices to be heard, their questions to be answered, and it has to be enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Jocelyn McCall:
    I think the way Ayers broke things down and categorized styles of teachings was really interesting and thought provoking. Using the terms that they did such as Tyrant feels very fitting for the style of teaching that strips away autonomy. As a student I have definitely seen all of the types of teachers described and when I dealt with teachers who preferred method was authoritative it really disturbed my motivation learn. In addition to that, it really resonated how Ayers framed democratic methods.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think that Ayers' way of talking about teaching is very good at explaining what they are and how they are taught and how they are effective or ineffective. I have seen the methods and strategies that he is talking about in use and it was helpful to have him distinguish them and describe them in more detail. I also hate the authoritarian method of teaching and think that there are a variety of other ways and theories about teaching that are more effective and intriguing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Ajaya-Kamari Barnhardt

    I like the way that Ayer's described the different teaching styles when it comes to teaching in school. Especially authoritarian I believe that this one is more of a governing style then a teaching style. A lot of times what happens in the school system we turn to being strict on a pathway. For students to be able to learn there has to be an adjust made for everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Lynnsi Joyce

    The standard methods of teaching he described in the chapter were definitely things I have seen in my educational journey. For the most part, my teachers fell somewhere in between the two but I have certainly had some teachers who were extreme one way or the other. There are positives to both methods but there are definitely some negatives, some more obvious than others.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ayers brings up two ways of teaching which I have seen in the classroom. He views teaching as a way for people to help other people reach their full potential. He views schooling as the practice of obedience and conformity. Some other thoughts came up while reading what my peers had to say. Somebody says students are seen more as products than individuals. When Ayers discusses the two ways of teaching this came to my mind

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anna Jarvis
    Ayers writes about methods of teaching. Authoritarian and Humanistic. I also thought the touch he had on white washing Native American children was very interesting. I did a project on that in High School for my AP Human Geography class. Native American history is one of my favorite things to learn. This example would be considered authoritarian because of the forcing of power, strict policies that were implicated. Humanistic revolves around the opposite principles; freedom, emotional intelligence, justice.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Brie Daniels- Teaching is connecting. Connecting with the youth and primarily the future. Who we teach can shift a generation mindset. So, stepping out from our traditional way of teaching can make a difference.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The two different teaching styles Ayer talks about are authoritarian and democratic. I have seen both of these teaching styles throughout my education. Throughout the article, the author talks about the pros and cons of each method

    ReplyDelete
  17. After reviewing the article Ayers, he mentions two styles that have been evident to me. Authoritarian and democratic I have seen both styles being used although I liked the democratic approach better I think balance of the two would be key and truly impact students. Not everyone learns the same way, I think giving a traditional and progressive approach would help students be more successful.

    -Janika G.W

    ReplyDelete
  18. Kimani Robinson
    Ayers approach to humanistic and authoritarian teaching styles points to what many people fear about the education system. Most schools are pretty authoritarian as far as following rules like a dress code or having certain hairstyles. They can also be authoritarian in what they teach and how they teach it. However, a humanist approach to teaching is absolutely crucial to be effective for the most people. The authority is also very much needed for when its simply time to sit down and listen.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Callum Amend:
    I think Ayer's description of how education's ultimate great purpose is to bring out the full humanity of students is an interesting perspective. He, of course, admits that there are many complications to this idea and that education is very often at best a form of obedience training and at worst actively dehumanizing and even traumatizing to students. The idea that education is for the purpose of making people the most human (compassionate, imperfect, able to think critically) means that the corollary must also be true: if we deny people a free, fair, and accurate education, or provide them purposefully with false information, we are denying their humanity. Thinking about what groups have historically been denied education, and still are, we see a continuous trend of marginalized people being denied not only human rights but humanity itself.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hannah Tijani

    Ayers' ideas are significant because they challenge traditional models of education that focus on rote memorization, standardized testing, and conformity. By emphasizing the importance of critical thinking, creativity, and social engagement, Ayers offers a new vision of education that is more responsive to the needs of diverse learners and communities. Ayers' ideas are relevant to current debates about education reform, particularly around issues of equity, diversity, and social justice. His emphasis on student empowerment and critical inquiry provides a powerful framework for educators who seek to create more inclusive and democratic classrooms.

    ReplyDelete

1/23…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...