Post a comment about the Ladson-Billings article. Note something interesting that you found (it can be surprising, disappointing, hope-inducing, etc.).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/23…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What is critical pedagogy and what you do think of it? What connections can you make between the idea of critical pedagogy and the Gutierrez...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
Ajaya-Kamari Barnhardt
ReplyDeleteSomething that I found interesting was the section named "Does your mother love you" This started off triggering because why is that a question and it then became worse after reading. It was talking about how a good parent can take care of their child and make them lunch and a bad parent is neglecting their child. That upset me a little bit because everyone's situation is different and because the parent doesn't or might not have time to make the lunch doesn't make them any less of a parent.
Danielle Hall:
ReplyDeleteWhile reading the article, I found it disappointing that there are so many negative stereotypes regarding poorer families within the education system (poor parents do not know how to parent, poor students cannot and do not want to succeed, etc.). While I was not necessarily surprised by this, I did find it interesting that recognizing the cycle of poverty that exists can be taken in the wrong direction. In social work, we are constantly discussing the systematic inequities that are present and produce a pattern of poverty. This is not because of anything the students or their families do, though; poor students are disadvantaged from the start. It is important to be aware of this cycle (to try to break it), but we cannot assume that this cycle is the only option. In my other education course this semester, we talk about the need for high expectations. If educators have low expectations for particular students, they will typically match that energy. That does not mean it is their fault, to clarify, but children need people to believe in them in order to succeed. That is the case with all students, and this article helped me recognize that students do not all receive the same simple encouragement to do well. It is almost as if poor students have a predetermined future, and understandably so, it is extremely difficult to break from that mold, which is quite upsetting to me.
Jocelyn McCall:
ReplyDeleteI found most of the concepts discussed in the article to be pretty accurate, as I've heard other teachers and admin talk about Black students and those who are in a lower class. I can especially relate to the fact that were encouraged to be good workers but not to be entrepreneurs or bosses. I was most disappointed by the redirect discussed that poor folk and Black people are told we don't value education. Even outside the United States, education has been one of the most prioritized mission of activists everywhere. The author made an excellent point that people are jailed or brutalized while trying to get those rights. All of this to say language and how we evaluate these things regarding this demographic of children shapes how we move forward to improving these situations.
Kimani Robinson:
ReplyDeleteTime and time again, children are made to suffer for factors that they had no control over. Time and time again, the children or parents are blamed for not keeping up with seemingly increasing demand for parental participation or financial supplementation. The problem is that people are being asked to devote more and more time and money to institutions that are not increasing the quality of service or product. I had parents who both worked full-time and didn't have much time to come to as many school functions as other parents. Fortunately, the school almost never made me feel bad about this. What matters is that the children are given everything they need to succeed, whether they come from humble or affluent means.
Erin Malloy:
ReplyDeleteI cannot say that I was at all surprised about what was introduced in this article. The associations made between socioeconomic status and motivation to succeed or even ability to learn were appalling and what is worse is that not much has changed. In classes I have previously heard about the policing of children in schools which usually is only seen in poor schools, with the population of the school being majority students of color. I do not think that school is a place anyone should feel as though they are being policed or controlled, and despite the fact that policing children and giving them a regiment to follow is not research-based it still occurs today.
Jade Kokason
ReplyDeleteOne section that stood out to me was called 'these children can't' which is an upsetting phrase in itself. This section talked about the long upheld notion that children that are poor simply can't keep up. This is neither right nor fair. It's doesn't take into account that not everyone has the same direct access to a lot of opportunities in life, but that does not mean that their own school system, where kids should be learning about how to find these opportunities, labels them in a "can't help you" box and pushes them along in the system. I feel like it is important to uphold equality in the school system, especially by teachers and administrators, to create a healthy and equal learning environment for their students.
Isabel Pepol-
ReplyDeleteI found it interesting that many neoliberal-inpired charter schools create their programs to keep children silent and under control. An example of this is when the students are required to walk down the hallway in absolute silence on black painted lines on the floor. This feels wrong because it resembles how people are treated in prisons. When children are not allowed to speak and are in a dull environment they feel like they cannot express themselves and I believe that that is not fair.
One thing i found interesting in the article was the section about school uniforms. In the article it was said that the belief is that the poor students needed the school uniforms to discipline them and keep their behavior under control and focus on their academic tasks. This is very interesting to me I think it's kind of messed up. In the beginning they discussed how uniforms were supposed to be for kids to focus on school and not what their peers are wearing , having any sort of competitiveness, and for students to look just like students but there was nothing to back up these claims and its apparent the real reasoning behind it.
ReplyDeleteBrie Daniels- I found the readings to be eye opening.It was mentioned that even black students who are considered middle class were put into the same category as poor blacks hit home for me. Yes, I was one of those students who was automatically seen as nothing more just because I was black. I also did not agree with the statement that privilege kids brought their lunch, and a white mom was praised for it. Why? Because my mother made my brother and I lunches due to the fact that we didn’t qualify for free lunch, and she didn’t find that school lunch was healthy for us. In the end this reading had me reflecting a lot on my own upbringing as a student.
ReplyDeleteAnna Rexrode-
ReplyDeleteI liked how in the article, it addressed different lies and stereotypes placed among underprivileged students whether it is economic status or race. I obviously do not enjoy the the fact that these are common stereotypes, but I liked how the author was able to address the topics for what they are, lies. Overall, it was very thought provoking and essentially allows the reader to debunk these lies as they read along. A part I found very interest was the sectioned called, "They don't value education." Ladson- Billings states that the common misconception of poor students is that they do not care about their education. Ladson-billing combats this and states how the meaning of education is different in comparison to wealthy students, but education is actually more meaningful for poor student than wealthy. They meaning of education for poor students is that it signifies them being able to come out of their struggles and live a better life. In comparison to wealthy students, who view education as just a credential. This was very interesting to read and it honestly reminds me of my own personal background with education. Because I did not grow up with much money if barely any growing up, the meaning for education for me is everything in hopes I can pursue a career that can support my family and I.
Anna Jarvis
ReplyDeleteThe article describes the various adverse situations poor students and students of color have to go through simply because of how they look and their financial status. People believe that these children aren't as smart or worthy of success just because of their background. For example, some students had a prison-like experience with extremely strict rules.
One part that hit my inner child was the "Does your mother love you" column. When the kid was crying about not wanting to go in the free lunch line, but also being upset he wasn't deemed as "special" because a parent didn't pack lunch for him. As a kid I grew up with a single mom and 3 siblings. I was the youngest, so I didn't understand divorce, but I knew lots of things changed quickly. Some weeks my mom would get emails from the school saying I had too much lunch debt and unless it was paid off, I wouldn't be able to eat. And that's just what happened, I went to school and they refused to give me (a 7-10 year old) food. The schools are who doesn't care. I never got packed lunches not because my mom didn't care, she just didn't have time. She worked from 6am to 5pm every day to earn enough money to just pay the bills. These circumstances do not determine the home life or intentions of a parent. A packed lunch isn't something that automatically makes you a good parent.
Vanessa Rodriguez:
ReplyDeleteOne myth I found disappointing would be the section “They just don’t want to work.” I hear people say this phrase a lot towards people in poverty, stating they lack “work ethic”. Many people in poverty work multiple jobs and long hours to be able to have an income that is sufficient to make ends meet. I believe that children who see their parents as hard workers will want to be hard workers too. It usually makes them want to do better in life and achieve more than their parents could.
Something interesting that this article said and made me think about was the educational reform renaissance. I thought that this wording was interesting as it was new to me and grabbed my attention from the beginning. This article made me wonder about how the future of educational reform looks and if there is hope of an ideal democratic and inclusive system in schools.
ReplyDeleteHannah Tijani
ReplyDeletethe author highlights the importance of acknowledging and valuing the cultural backgrounds and experiences of students in the classroom. One particularly interesting point made by the author is the idea that culturally relevant pedagogy is not a one-size-fits-all approach, but rather a framework that must be adapted and personalized for each unique classroom and student population
Callum Amend:
ReplyDeleteOne quote that stuck out to me from this article was, "Neoliberal schooling strategies presume that poor parents and families need lessons about how to be responsible, caring adults rather than tutorials about how to deal with hostile and inflexible bureaucracies." I hadn't really considered how public schools often punish poor parents or blame them for their children's lack of success (while this is almost never done to wealthy parents). It is the easy, but morally reprehensible, route to blame poor parents for their situation rather than consider the many systems that have failed them.
Lynnsi Joyce
ReplyDeleteThe article is very heavily based in the harm that stereotypes cause and how these stereotypes enter the school system. Specifically the stereotypes and biases around poor students and even more specifically, poor students of color, are addressed. This article outlines how educators' bias towards these student only feeds the cycle even more and it creates a deeper divide between students.
Something that stood out to me after reading this article a lot of negative stereotypes were mentioned in this article, it was disappointing to hear about them the stereotypes of poorer families with less income, the poor students of color there is always some form of stereotypical things when it comes to people of color or people with lower income it shows why there is division in the school system.
ReplyDelete-Janika