Can you give an example of an experience you have had as a student that seemed traditional? How about progressive? Please very briefly one or the other. Was it a good experience? Why or why not?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/23…Labaree’s “From Citizen to Consumers”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What is critical pedagogy and what you do think of it? What connections can you make between the idea of critical pedagogy and the Gutierrez...
-
What do you think the filmmaker is trying to convey about democracy? What was new to you? What did the film contribute to your understanding...
-
Have you done much thinking about democracy and what our schools might/should have to do with it? If so, what have you been thinking? If not...
Ajaya-Kamari Barnhardt
ReplyDeleteI would say an experience that seemed traditional and having to sit in front of the teacher. They are speaking and I am listening taking notes. I feel that is the most traditional situation when it comes to be a student at schools. A progressive experience would be adding computers and technology into learning. Textbooks were the root of how students go their education. Now there are PowerPoints and the use of technology that has progressed how students learn. It is always a good experience getting an education and when there is a system it does get easier as well.
Danielle Hall:
ReplyDeleteGrowing up in a rural, conservative town, I have found that most of my experiences fit the traditional schooling models. In almost every class, I was taught content and how to succeed on an exam, and that is it. For example, every year my friends and I had a tradition of asking our math teachers why we were learning what we were. Every single time we were told, “because it is on the SOL test.” Through this schooling experience, I learned how the system works, and I have always done well in school, but my school smarts do not necessarily translate to real-life experiences, so it was not the best experience for me. I am able to think of one specific progressive schooling experience that I had in my ninth-grade Earth Science class. This teacher was known throughout the county for being a little “crazy” and using a non-traditional approach in her classroom. We had a mini field trip almost every day so she could teach us about the Earth out in nature where we could see what she was talking about. Whenever we were in the classroom we were doing projects, never worksheets. She was all about application, but she still had tests due to the requirements from the school, and to be completely honest, I did very poorly on those tests since I was not used to her method of teaching. That being said, I learned more from that class than any other class in reality because instead of memorizing the topics, I learned how to use the information I learned in the real world, so I would say it was a good experience and one I will never forget.
Jocelyn McCall:
ReplyDeleteReflecting upon my experience within the education system, I am finding out that there are very few times that I was not following a traditional modal of learning. Most of all, my courses were aimed at measuring success with tests, writing, and control. I would say now that I am in college, it has shifted a bit. Most professors are not very pressed about testing as a means of learning, they are additionally more interested in student thought and well being. as far as traditional learning a time I think about was my 8th grade English class,where she was very authoritative.The entire period was almost silent every day. She had to force us to speak and everybody dreaded going. It was very day ruining; it felt unsafe to share my thoughts and made me less enthused about writing.
The first time I could really think of where I did progressive learning, as Dewey would describe, was probably in highschool during my senior year when I took World Religions. I feel the classroom had more of a democratic feel to it. I am definitely more eager to learn in my current classroom settings, where they acknowledge we are both human.
Anna Jarvis
ReplyDeleteI've had both experiences of progressive and traditional. I was in a program called iLab that was based around the principles of John Dewey. The classes within this program were all hands-on. We went on dozens of field trips each year studying many different topics, did lots of community service, and had many opportunities. For example, I got to do a contest for a local non-profit organization where we researched Virginia Beach's native trees, and made an environmental plan on where would be the most beneficial to plant them. I was a finalist and got to plant the trees myself along with other students who entered!
On the traditional note. The best example of this I can think of is math class. Any math class I've taken has been the most traditional and boring curriculum. It's pure memorization, which is really difficult for me when it's not something I can necessarily experience myself.
I would describe the 15 or so years I spent in school to have been traditional. I would go to class, sit down, listen, take notes, have quizzes and tests. Going to school was not a matter of learning but merely sitting down to have teachers give you rules and you are supposed to absorb information as sponges like Dewey discusses. One class that stands out to me to be one of the first and few to be progressive was my senior year government class. There was information to learn and few tests and quizzes but there was also a lot of hands on per say. Instead of just doing the work and getting through there were activities in which we would have "freedom". A lot of the learning was through experience. One example would be how we would do open debates. In one of the videos Dewey talks about teachers being a guide and help you lead to growth not through cramming knowledge. I look back at my teacher from this class and his teaching was like that. I think this was a great experience experience because I take what I learned and did in the class way more than I have any traditional class that was focused on consuming knowledge and regurgitating it back through tests rather than understand the information.
ReplyDeleteJade Kokason
ReplyDeleteAn experience that I had in school that was traditional was lecture. The teacher would lecture on the subject and encourage us to take notes, and we were told that it was to prepare us for college and our tests. A non-traditional experience that I had was I-pads in algebra class. It added an extra element to math that I feel like might have engaged us more, which is why I feel that it was a better way; while I also didn't mind the lecture since I was a senior.
Erin Malloy:
ReplyDeleteOne example of a traditional schooling experience that I had was definitely in my math classes in high school. My teachers would essentially just lecture the formulas and problems, give us one example of how to solve it, and then expect everyone to be able to reproduce what they just exemplified. One example of a progressive schooling experience that I had was in one of my high school history courses. In the class we were all assigned jobs that are seen in the court room and then we had to perform those jobs as best we could in order to learn about the court system and its inner workings. I think that the progressive experience was positive in that it did not require me to memorize every job in the court system and then take a test on it, instead we got to see how it worked by performing it ourselves.
Isabel Pepol-
ReplyDeleteThroughout my schooling, I was most commonly taught in a traditional classroom rather than a progressive one. Test taking was a huge part of my education. From elementary to high school, my testing scores were extremely important to the school and so was improving them if need be. Overall, this experience made me feel like they were teaching to create better scores rather than creating great students. It felt like the skill of memorization was more important than actually understanding the subject matter.
Vanessa Rodriguez
ReplyDeleteAn experience that I had that seemed traditional was the typical curriculum delivered by a teacher in a classroom setting. A progressive experience would be online schooling, where I was able to take classes asynchronously and synchronously. I was able to learn at my own time, place, and pace in my asynchronous class. Unlike progressive learning, traditional learning makes all of those factors remain constant for every student in the classroom. I believe that traditional learning provides students with structure and stability.
Brie Daniels- Like most I’ve received “traditional” schooling with extra help. My experience wasn’t that great until my mindset changed. Senior year of high school was when that change happened. I stopped complaining and started enjoying. Which then boosted my grades and interactions with teachers. So yes, schooling now isn’t ideal, but can soon change, once everyone stops teaching curriculum.
ReplyDeleteWhen reflecting on my time in school, I feel that many of the classroom experiences I have had were more traditional. In most of my classes I would sit at a desk, as the teacher stood at the front of the class and lectured from a powerpoint with the goal of preparing us for a test. When I think of my experiences with progressive teaching, I think back to my german class in high school. This was always a bit of a smaller class, and I feel that this was advantageous as there was always a big emphasis on our individual learning and small group activities. I was given more freedom to interact with the material in my own way, and implement what I learned in small group activities and projects. I remember this class very fondly, as it was a break from the status quo that I experienced with most of my other classes, and in doing so, I feel that I have retained much more information from that german class in the years after taking it when compared with my other high school classes. I feel that with a more progressive learning experience, I was able to more deeply connect with the material in a way that better suited by individual learning style, as opposed to having to learn material through pure memorization which I would typically experience in a more traditional classroom setting.
ReplyDelete^ Michael Morrissey
DeleteReflecting, on my time in school I moved around a couple times. I think i went to three different elementary schools. Although it was elementary i think we had more traditional moments. It was very structured the education system and sometimes not structured at all. Once i moved county's it was a completely different experience. We were given our own laptop; a new freedom with respectable limitations. Some math assignments would be online through a very progressive and useful website though i can't remember the name. I remember liking math for the first time in middle school and that continued till now i think eventually we'll slowly move away to strictly traditional and more progressive ways of teaching and learning.
ReplyDeleteI've had my fair share of traditional and progressive learning. Most of my traditional Learning was in high school and college. The most common one was sitting in a lecture and being required to take notes about what the teacher would say. There would be no PowerPoint, no indicators of when to take notes, and what material was going to be on the test. This made it very very hard for me to understand the material because when I didn't understand something and I would raise my hand, my teacher would make me feel dumb for inquiring.
ReplyDeleteThen I experienced progressive learning. Progressive learning for me was when I was in high school and I got to learn hands-on to be a dental assistant in some of my classes as a junior. Learning how to be a dental assistant at 16 years old is obviously not traditional, but this was the most beneficial Learning I have ever experienced. I was able to be so successful in anatomy back at school because I was already learned it for dental class. But I was able to retain the knowledge better through my other class in comparison to Natalie because I was more interested in engaging with the material because it was not being taught traditionally.
Hannah Tijani
ReplyDeleteI had always stayed in the same schools throughout my childhood but one some things I can recall about the traditional ways they would teach were some teachers were mainly forced on having us write our own notes yes, in theory it sounds like a productive idea but most times i would miss important information or I'd just write down things that weren't as important. Even coming to college It's mostly taking notes on your own time and studying off of them. We never know what will actually be on the test. Coming to college its mostly test over tests. Not even the non-test takers a chance to raise their grade.
Traditional schooling has been most of my school experience. Sitting down in class, lectures, note taking, and memorizing the notes to take the test. Most of my classes outside of my major still include all of those things. However, I am lucky to be in a major where that kind of teaching style doesn't work and progressive is the way. Going out in the world, incorporating all the things we've learned in class and putting it out there, doing something with our practice. It makes a huge difference in my work ethic and how I grasp the material.
ReplyDeleteEmma Weatherholtz
DeleteI think that in elementary school times tables test would be an example of more traditional schooling. I think that this is the most practiced old school form of teaching multiplication and division as well. I think that the heavy emphasis on memorization and sped in these activities is traditional. I think that some activities that included technology and are inclusive to people who are scared to speak up or interact in person. I think that discussion posts are progressive to a certain extent. I think that in person sped tests on your memorization when you are supposed to be being tested on your skills is very negative and traditional.
ReplyDeleteThe most problematic traditional schooling method is how teachers teach their lessons based on the SOL tests. They are teaching a whole year's worth of information based on one test at the end of the year initially made to see how good or bad the teacher is. Progressive learning is more hands-on activities and learning about the real world. Progressive was a good experience because the information taught to me stuck with me.
ReplyDeleteLynnsi Joyce
ReplyDeleteA lot of my science classes in high school had the very traditional teacher at the front of the room lecturing at the students while we take notes. It wasn't necessarily a bad thing, but my classes that had teachers that weren't as fun to listen to, it was painful. In middle school, though, my gifted teacher had a history unit where instead of us watching videos or reading books, we were archaeologists that excavated a sandbox. We then took what we found and did research to figure out what it was and the history behind it. Both of these examples had good things about them. The archaeology was definitely more fun but it was just as impactful as the anatomy lecturing from high school.
I've experienced traditional schooling more than progressive. Sitting in class taking notes, being lectured about different topics, and taking test. I remember when I was in 10th grade one of my teachers only taught traditionally we would come into class he would lecture and after lecturing he would put notes on the projector for the class to copy I disliked this class very much and I felt as if I wasn't retaining any beneficial l information because of the way we were taught. I like the progressive approach a bit of traditional teaching I think balancing both and also figuring out what works best for your students.
ReplyDelete-Janika G.W
Callum Amend:
ReplyDeleteI have had experiences with both traditional and progressive education. When I was 7-9, I went to a private school for children with disabilities. It was a Montessori school that believed in hands on education and practical application of materials. For the most part, it was one of my favorite experiences in terms of learning. It was far more student involved and democratic than my experiences in public school.
Kimani Robinson
ReplyDeleteI went through a pretty traditional public school grade system. There were sometimes things done at my school that I thought were unique and progressive for a small town, and I guess some things were when you think relatively. Nearly everything in fact traditional. I had teachers who I'm pretty sure were progressive in personal values, but got the idea that there was only so much freedom for a teacher in the classroom. I do remember talking briefly about queer history during my senior year U.S. History class, which was aptly met with a broad spectrum of reactions among the students, but everyone was mostly respectful at the end of the day. My school experience has mostly been a straightforward path with well-meaning teachers sprinkling engaging learning activities along the way.